Towards predicting biochar impacts on plant-available soil nitrogen content

Biochars can improve soil health but have been widely shown to reduce plant-available nitrogen (N) owing to their high carbon (C) content, which stimulates microbial N-immobilization. However, because biochars contain large amounts of C that are not microbially available, their total elemental C:N ratio does not correspond well with impacts on soil N. We hypothesized that impacts on soil plant-available N would relate to biochar mineralizable-C (C_min) content, and that C:N ratios of the mineralizable biochar component could provide a means for predicting conditions of net soil N-mineralization or -immobilization. We conducted two laboratory experiments, the first measuring biochar C_min from respiration of isotopically labeled barley biochars manufactured at 300, 500, and 750 °C, and the second characterizing C_min by proxy measurements for ten biochars from six feedstocks at several temperatures. For both experiments, soils were incubated with 2% biochar by mass to determine impacts to soil N-mineralization. Contrary to expectation, all the biochars increased soil N-mineralization relative to unamended soils. Also unexpected, higher temperature (500 and 700 °C) barley biochars with less C_min stimulated more soil decomposition and more soil N-mineralization than a 350 °C barley biochar. However, across diverse biochar feedstocks and production methods, none of the biochar characteristics correlated with soil N-mineralization. The finding of improved soil N-mineralization adds complexity to the range of soil N responses that can be expected in response to biochar amendment. Because of the limited ability to predict soil N responses from biochar properties, users should monitor soil N to manage soil fertility.