高级检索+

不同粪污处理模式的潜在环境影响和经济效益评价

Environmental impact and economic benefit evaluation of different treatment modes of manure

  • 摘要: 为了评价好氧堆肥工艺和黑膜沼气工艺两种粪污处理模式的潜在环境影响和经济效益,本研究采用生命周期评价的方法分析烟台市牟平区某奶牛场两种粪污处理模式的潜在环境影响,并通过分析处理过程中的成本及产出,评价两种粪污处理模式的经济效益。结果表明:好氧堆肥工艺处理功能单位鲜牛粪在生命周期中的耗电量为25.98 kW·h,其中粉碎包装阶段最大,占总耗电量的89.80%;污染物排放总量为44.914 2 kg,其中CO2、CO、SO2、CH4、NH3、NOx排放量分别为42.903 5,0.040 3,0.267 4,0.551 4,0.961 2,0.190 4 kg; CH4、NH3排放量在堆肥阶段最大,分别占各自总排放量的89.99%、100%;CO2、CO、SO2、NOx排放量在粉碎包装阶段最大,分别占各自总排放量的58.18%、89.83%、86.65%、79.15%;好氧堆肥工艺处理功能单位鲜牛粪在生命周期中标准化后的全球变暖潜力、环境酸化潜力、富营养化潜力分别为0.007 4,0.063 1,0.005 7,综合影响潜力为0.024 7。黑膜沼气工艺处理单位功能液态粪污在生命周期中的耗电量为0.17 kW·h,电力全部消耗在沼液泵出阶段;污染物排放总量为0.658 7 kg,其中CO2、CO、SO2、CH4、NOx的排放量分别为0.636 0,0.000 3,0.020 9,0.000 4,0.001 1 kg; CO2、SO2排放量在沼气燃烧阶段最大,分别占各自总排放量的40.27%、91.87%;CO、CH4、NOx的排放全部来自沼液泵出阶段;黑膜沼气工艺处理单位功能液态粪污在生命周期中标准化后的全球变暖潜力、环境酸化潜力、富营养化潜力分别为0.000 1,0.000 6,0.000 0,综合影响潜力为0.000 2。好氧堆肥工艺功能单位鲜牛粪处理成本为327.97元,经济效益为92.03元;黑膜沼气工艺功能单位液态粪污处理成本为0.10元,不产生经济效益。说明对于粪污产生量较小的中小型养殖场,可采用好氧堆肥工艺和投资、运行成本低的黑膜沼气工艺共同处理粪污。最后,提出添加除氨菌系,接种复合菌剂,降低污染物排放;减少水力滞留时间,改进液态粪污处理工艺;生产高附加值有机肥料,提高好氧堆肥工艺经济效益的对策建议。

     

    Abstract: The aim of the study was to evaluate the potential environmental impact and economic benefits of aerobic composting process and black membrane biogas process. In this study, life cycle assessment(LCA) was used to analyze the potential environmental impact of the two treatment modes in a dairy farm in Muping District, Yantai city,and the economic benefits of the two treatment modes were evaluated by analyzing the cost and output of the treatment process. The results showed that the power consumption of fresh cow dung in the life cycle of aerobic composting process for treating fresh cow dung with unit function was 25.98 kW·h, and the power consumption was the largest in the crushing and packaging stage, accounting for 89.80% of the total power consumption. The total amount of pollutants discharged was 44.914 2 kg, in which the emissions of CO2, CO, SO2, CH4, NH3 and NOx were 42.903 5, 0.040 3, 0.267 4, 0.551 4, 0.961 2 and 0.190 4 kg respectively. The emission of CH4 and NH3 was the largest in composting stage, accounted for 89.99% and 100% of the total emissions respectively. The emissions of CO2, CO, SO2 and NOx were the largest in the crushing and packaging stage, accounted for 58.18%, 89.83%, 86.65% and 79.15% of the total emissions respectively. The standardized global warming potential, environmental acidification potential and eutrophication potential in the life cycle of aerobic composting process for treating fresh cow dung with unit function were 0.007 4, 0.063 1 and 0.005 7, and the comprehensive impact potential was 0.024 7. The power consumption in the life cycle of black membrane biogas process for treating liquid manure with unit function is 0.17 kW·h, and all the power consumption was in the biogas slurry pumping stage. The total amount of pollutants dischargedwas 0.658 7 kg, in which the emissions of CO2, CO, SO2, CH4 and NOx were 0.636 0, 0.000 3, 0.020 9, 0.000 4 and 0.001 1 kg respectively. The emission of CO2 and SO2 was the largest in the biogas combustion stage, accounted for 40.27% and 91.87% of the total emissions respectively. The emissions of CO, CH4 and NOx were all come from the biogas slurry pumping stage. The standardized global warming potential, environmental acidification potential and eutrophication potential of black membrane biogas process for treating liquid manure with unit function in life cycle were 0.000 1, 0.000 6 and 0.000 0 respectively, and the comprehensive impact potential was 0.000 2.The cost of aerobic composting process for treating fresh cow dung with unit function was 327.97 yuan, and the economic benefit was 92.03 yuan. The cost of liquid manure treatment by black membrane biogas process with unit function was 0.10 yuan, which had no economic benefit. It indicated that aerobic composting process and black membrane biogas process with low investment and operation cost could be used to treat manure in small and medium-sized farms with small manure production.Finally, Some countermeasures and suggestions were put forward to improve the economic benefits of aerobic composting process by adding ammonia-removing bacteria and inoculating compound microbial inoculum to reduce pollutant emission, reducing the hydraulic retention time to improve the treatment process of liquid manure. producing high value-added organic fertilizer.

     

/

返回文章
返回