高级检索+

盐旱复合胁迫条件下生物炭对作物产量及水分利用效率影响的Meta分析

The effects of biochar on crop yield and water use efficiency under combined salt and drought stress: A meta−analysis

  • 摘要: 盐旱复合胁迫是较单一胁迫更为严峻的作物生产力制约因素,生物炭已被证实可有效缓解其对作物的胁迫限制。然而,由于土壤条件、作物类型与生物炭性质间存在较强异质性,其调控效应尚缺乏系统认识。该研究采用Meta分析整合全球19篇符合纳入标准文献中的227组观察结果(产量150组,水分利用效率77组),定量评估了生物炭对盐旱复合胁迫下作物产量和水分利用效率的总体效应及其影响因素。结果表明:1)施用生物炭可使作物产量和水分利用效率分别提高5.6%(95% CI:2.9%~8.4%,P<0.001)和6.2%(95% CI:2.7%~9.8%,P<0.001)。其促进效应具有明显情境依赖性:在盆栽试验、C4作物、电导率<2 dS/m、pH 7.5~8.5的土壤以及轻至中度盐旱复合胁迫条件下更为显著。2)不同生物炭性质对产量和水分利用效率的影响存在差异:木本类和高温热解(≥600 ℃)生物炭的增产效应较强,而秸秆类和低温热解(≤400 ℃)生物炭对水分利用效率的提升效应较强。3)赤池信息量准则(Akaike information criterion,AIC)权重结果显示,施用量、热解温度、盐旱复合胁迫类型、土壤类型、土壤pH和作物类型对产量的调控效应贡献度相对较高,而水分利用效率效应量的高权重变量较少。在62组产量–水分利用效率配对中,74.19%的表现为产量与水分利用效率同步提升,表明生物炭总体具有较强的增产-节水“双赢”效应,但在高强度盐旱复合胁迫下该效应明显减弱。总体而言,生物炭在盐旱复合胁迫农田中具有促进作物增产和节水协同提升的应用潜力。

     

    Abstract: Combined salt and drought stress poses a more pronounced constraint on crop productivity than either stress alone. While biochar has been shown to effectively mitigate the adverse effects, a systematic understanding of its regulatory mechanisms remains elusive due to the heterogeneity in soil type, crop cultivars and biochar properties. This study therefore conducted a meta−analysis synthesizing 19 publications containing 227 observations (150 for yield, 77 for water use efficiency) to scrutinize biochar effects on yield and water use efficiency. Random meta−forest model was employed to identify the key factors of biochar on yield and water use efficiency. Additionally, four−quadrant analysis was performed using 62 paired observations containing both yield and water use efficiency to further explore the synergistic responses to biochar application. Results showed that the application of biochar increased crop yield by 5.6% (95% confidence interval, 2.9%−8.4%) and water use efficiency by 6.2% (2.7%−9.8%). These promoting effects were more pronounced under pot experiments, C4 crops, soils with electrical conductivity (EC) < 2 dS/m and pH 7.5~8.5, as well as mild to moderate combined salt–drought stress. Moreover, distinct responses emerged between yield and water use efficiency depending on biochar properties. Specifically, woody−derived or high−temperature (≥600℃) biochar exhibited stronger yield promotion, whereas straw−derived or low−temperature (≤400℃) biochar demonstrated greater enhancement of water use efficiency. AIC (Akaike information criterion) weight analysis further revealed that the application rate, pyrolysis temperature, salt–drought stressed type, soil type, soil pH, and crop type were the dominant modulators of yield, whereas considerably fewer factors carried high importance for water use efficiency. Notably, biochar induced concurrent increases in both yield and water use efficiency in 74.19% of the 62 paired observations, revealing a synergistic “win–win” effect on yield enhancement and water conservation. However, this synergistic benefit was substantially weakened under high−intensity combined salt–drought stress. Collectively, these findings highlight the potential of biochar as a promising amendment to concurrently improve crop productivity and water conservation in agricultural systems subjected to combined salt–drought stress.

     

/

返回文章
返回