高级检索+

年径流丰枯分类方法的效果研究

Research on the Effects of Annual Runoff Wet-dry Classification Methods

  • 摘要: 研究年径流丰枯分类方法的效果,对流域水文分析和水资源管理具有重要意义。从年径流过程相似性、总量差异性、分布均匀性等3个方面,定义了3个对应的丰枯分类效果评价指标,即相似指数、差异指数和均布指数。根据所采用的丰枯分类指数,将年径流丰枯分类方法划分为综合指数型、关系指数型和综合关系指数型等3类,并从3类方法中各选取3种代表方法。以黑河流域莺落峡站为例,利用选取的9种代表方法对该站年径流进行丰枯分类,分析不同方法的丰枯分类效果。结果表明:丰枯分类结果对所采用分类方法的种类及内部参数很敏感,不同方法的分类结果差异明显,相同方法的分类效果也可能因地而异;定义的3种评价指标可以反映不同方法的分类效果,丰枯类别分布均匀化有利于改善分类效果;总体而言,综合关系指数型方法的分类效果最好,综合指数型方法次之,关系指数型方法最差;当年径流量和年径流过程的一致性较好时,常规方法相比综合评价方法可能具有更好的分类效果。研究结果可为合理划分流域年径流丰枯状态提供科学依据。

     

    Abstract: An investigation of the effects of annual runoff wet-dry classification methods is of important significance for hydrological analysis and water resources management in a river basin. Three corresponding indexes,i.e. similarity index,difference index and uniformity index,are defined for evaluating the wet-dry classification effects from the view of annual runoff process similarity,volume difference and distribution uniformity of wet-dry categories. According to the adopted classification index types,annual runoff wet-dry classification methods are divided into three categories,i.e. comprehensive index-based(CI-based)category,relationship index-based(RI-based)category and comprehensive relationship index-based(CRI-based)category. Moreover,nine representative methods are selected from the three categories,and each category contains three methods. Finally,Yingluoxia Station of Heihe River Basin is taken as a case study,where the selected nine methods are applied to the annual runoff wet-dry classification of the station,and the wet-dry classification effects of different methods are analyzed. The results show that(1) annual runoff wet-dry classification results are very sensitive to classification methods and their internal parameters,classification results of different methods are obviously different,and the classification effects of the same method may also differ from region to region;(2) the three defined indexes may reflect the wet-dry classification effects of different methods,and the uniform distribution of wet-dry classes is beneficial for the improvement of wet-dry classification effects;(3) overall,the classification effects of the methods of CRI-based category are the best,those of CI-based category are the second,and those of RI-based category are the worst;and(4) the classification results of conventional methods may be more reasonable than those of comprehensive methods when the annual runoff volume and process are relatively consistent. The results can provide a scientific basis for reasonably classifying annual runoff wet-dry states of a river basin.

     

/

返回文章
返回